ATV Winter Tires Vs. Mud And Snow: What's The Difference? | Hunt or Shred

People often think that winter and mud and snow tires are the same. This is a mistake. Here’s what you need to know about winter tires vs mud and snow tires.

Winter tires, as the name suggests, are designed for snowy and sub-zero conditions. They ensure that you have enough traction to drive with comfort on snow. Mud and snow tires can be driven in muddy and snowy conditions but don't do well when temperatures fall before 45 degrees Fahrenheit.

Now, since these tires are so similar in terms of build and the conditions you're supposed to drive them in, you might be tempted to just choose mud and snow tires and be done with it. However, that's a mistake. In this article, we'll help you figure out the difference between winter tires and mud and snow tires so you know which one you need when you take your ATV out for a spin.

There are evident disparities between the two types, which are discussed below. The information provided comes from our experts who know the nitty-gritty of ATVs and have a vast knowledge of different types of tires. So without further ado, let's start with this ATV winter tires vs mud and snow comparison.

Table of contents


What Are Winter Tires?

Winter tires are designed to be used in sub-zero conditions and when there is a significant amount of snow on the ground. Even after severe snowstorms, they help keep your ATV and four-wheelers on the road.

When it comes to roads in the wintertime, the correct tire is crucial. December roads are notoriously unpredictable, from blizzard conditions to ice and snow. These circumstances put a strain on a tire's ability to offer traction.

Winter tires, which are specifically built to function in winter situations, are the ideal choice for the mixture of freezing temperatures, ice, and snowfall. Winter tires have a few characteristics that set them apart from mud and snow tires. Let's have a look at some of them.

Tread Rubber

An all-season or midsummer tire's tread material tightens in freezing temperatures, which is why it isn't able to offer enough traction. To address this, winter tire tread rubber compositions are designed to stay supple, ensuring that the tire grips the road more effectively.

Unique Patterns

Winter tires are distinguished by their deeper tread levels and distinctive tread patterns. Wider tread depths help with traction on the ice by reducing snow accumulation. The tread patterns on winter tires are intended to drain snow and slush while also expelling water.

Biting Edges

Winter tires have a higher number of biting surfaces and sipe concentrations or hundreds of microscopic openings in the tread that assist adhesion on ice.

These features help winter tires maintain their grip on icy roadways. The tire's gentler rubber formula helps it retain traction on a slippery road, while the broader tread pattern delves deeper through the ice, and the unique tread geometries channel water and debris. In conclusion, winter tires are less likely to cause skids or crashes than mud and snow tires, and they can also help you move and stop quicker.

What Are Mud and Snow Tires?

Mud and snow tires are all-season tires that have been authorized by the Rubber Manufacturers Association for usage in both snowy and muddy environments. The "M+S" label is usually seen on these tires.

Mud and snow tires, unlike summer tires and even lower-performance all-season tires, typically contain ridges that improve their performance in slippery weather. Even though some summer tires theoretically match the M&S tire standards, most makers exclusively label mud and snow tires as tires with enhanced traction qualities.

The rubber used in mud and snow tires is made to constantly adapt to cold conditions, and the deep grooves in the tread are intended to grab ice and snow and throw it over the edges, clearing the channels for more of it.

Differences between Winter Tires and Mud and Snow Tires

When ATVs leave the manufacturer, they are generally equipped with mud and snow tires. It's no surprise that they're so successful because they're designed to give a surprisingly calm ride and year-round efficiency. Mud and snow tires are suited for a variety of circumstances, including wet pavements and mild winter riding.

On the other hand, a winter tire is designed to be used in temperatures of 45°F or below. These tires have a special tread compound that performs well in cold weather and in snowy and icy conditions. Winter tires are thus ideal for ATV users who experience harsh winter conditions with a lot of snow and ice and need something that will allow them to maintain grip and traction on wet and icy roads.

Below, we’ve shared some major differences between winter tires and mud and snow tires to help you understand the qualities of each.

Compound Differences

The compound distinctions between a winter tire and an all-season tire are significant. Although all-season mud and snow tires will keep you going in the winter with adequate traction on ice and snow, a winter tire is made of a special composition that stays malleable and improves grip in snowy conditions.

The very same compound characteristics make a winter tire unsuitable for use in the summertime and in mud. In extremely high temperatures, the winter tire's composition will weaken, and tread deformation can lead to poor driving and early tire wear.

Variations in Siping

On slippery terrains like rain, slush, and ice, tire siping enhances traction. A tire's sipes provide a biting edge for adhesion. The more the sipes there are, the more biting corners will be present. Winter tires have a lot more siping than mud and snow tires. This improves their traction on wet roads and slippery surfaces.

Some all-season tires will have greater siping but a tougher tread composition to decrease deformation. With a lighter composition, other all-season tires will have much less siping. A great winter tire has the right combination of siping and tread composition to perform well in rain, snow, and ice.

Tread Depth

Many ATV tires, whether they're for winter, summer, or mud and snow, have a tread depth of between 9/32 and 12/32 inches when fresh. In principle, a broader tread depth provides superior traction in milder circumstances such as unloaded ice or mud.

On the firm surface of the road, however, excessive tread depth might cause tread wiggle. A tread depth of 4/32 will still give a smooth and secure drive on snow, ice, or rainfall. It's also important to note that when tires reach 4/32 tread depth, they should be replaced as soon as possible.

Tire Life

All-season tires, including those labeled M&S, are designed to be used all year, hence the title "all-season." That's the all-season tire's most obvious benefit. Winter tires are seasonal tires that should be removed from the vehicle when summer comes around as they won't perform well in the heat.

Ride Comfort

The tire core structure and tread composition will have a significant impact on ride comfort. Winter tires are built with winter characteristics in mind. Even though there aren't many differences between mud and snow and winter tires when it comes to manufacturing, there are some things you need to keep in mind.

In cold locations, a winter tire's winter-specific composition can provide greater stability for riders. As the studs come into contact with rough surfaces, a studded winter tire can provide a rough ride.

Which Tire is Right for you?

Every driver should consider whether or not they can even drive in the winter with all-season tires. If you think you can drive your ATV in the winter with mud and snow tires, you should go with them. However, you should be aware of your route's conditions. Mud and snow tires are suitable even for winter if you don't get a lot of snow and ice in your area.

If you get plenty of snowfall and the winters are harsh, then driving an ATV with mud and snow tires won't be a good option. They won't perform well, and the handling of your ATV will be compromised. Winter tires will offer improved traction, resulting in increased performance and safety.

You might think that buying winter tires and then replacing them again during the summer season will set you back a pretty penny, but it's more important to think about your safety. Spending a few hundred dollars is better than getting into an accident due to the wrong set of tires and then spending thousands of dollars on ATV repairs. Mud and snow tires don't perform well on extremely slippery and icy roads, so it's not worth using them in tough conditions.




25 years old. I'm from PA. I love horseback riding and riding ATV's. My husband and I own a farm and our ATV's help us work and have fun.

Read More About Elizabeth